CHAPTER II
DISCUSSION
A. Descriptive
According to Oxford
Advanced Learner’s, descriptive is saying what something is like; describing
something: the descriptive passages in the novel.[2]
Meaning
of descriptive in English:
- serving to describe or inform or characterized by
description; "the descriptive variable"; "a descriptive
passage"
- concerned with phenomena (especially language) at a
particular period without considering historical antecedents;
"synchronic linguistics"; "descriptive linguistics"
- describing the structure of a language;
"descriptive linguistics simply describes language"[3]
B. Meaning
According to Oxford
Advanced Learner’s, Meaning is the thing or idea
that sounds, word, sign, etc. represent: what’s the meaning of this word?
Words often have several meaning ‘Honesty’? He doesn’t know the meaning of the
word![4]
Descriptive meaning isa dimension of expression meaning. The descriptive meaning of a sentence, its proposition, is a concept that provides a mental
description of the kind of situations it potentially refers to. The descriptive
meaning of a word or a grammatical form is its contribution to the descriptive
meanings of the sentences in which the word or grammatical form may occur.
(Alternative terms: propositional meaning, truth-conditional meaning.)According
to truth-conditional theories, an adequate descriptive semantic theory
needs to provide a recursive and compositional characterization of values for
sentences which determine the truth conditions of each sentence.[5]
Descriptive meaning is contained in the meaning of each word. Meaning
indicated by the symbol itself. So, if someone says water, then the issue is a liquid
substance that is used for bathing, washing or drinking. Water that the meaning
is that there is water in the bucket, in the bath, or in a baking dish. If
someone said, "Take a glass of water," then surely brought water
instead of juice or mercury. Understand the meaning of the word water, because
it brings the water as we wish.[6]
C. Dimensions
of Descriptive Meaning
1. Intrinsic
dimension
Intrinsic dimensions are semantic properties an element
possesses in and ofitself, without (overt) reference to other elements.
a. Quality
What we shall call quality is at one and the same time
the most obvious and important dimension of variation within descriptive
meaning, and the one about which we shall say the least. It is this which
constitutes the difference between red and green, dog and cat,
apple and orange, run and walk, hate and fear, here and
there. Pure differences of quality are to be observed only between items
which are equal on the scales of intensity and specificity.
b. Intensity
Descriptive
meaning may vary in intensity, without change of quality. For instance, one
would not wish to say that large and huge differ in quality: they
designate the same area of semantic quality space, but differ in intensity. It
is characteristic of intensity differences that they yield normal results in
the following test frame.
c. Specificity
Differences of descriptive specificity show up in various
logical properties. These differ according to the exact type of
specificity involved (see below). For one major type of specificity, these
properties include, for instance, unilateral entailment.
For examples :
It's a dog unilaterally
entails It's an animal.
It's not an animal unilaterally
entails It's not a dog.
Note also that dogs and other animals is
normal, but not ?animals and other dogs.
From all this, we can
conclude that dog is
more specific than animal (alternatively,
animal is more general
than dog). Similarly, slap is more specific than hit, scarlet is more specific
than red, woman is more
specific than person .
d. Vagueness
We
shall say that the meaning of a word is vague
to the extent that the criteria governing its use are not precisely
statable. Before examining this notion in greater detail, it is necessary to
make as clear a distinction as possible between it and certain other notions
with which it is often coupled in discussions, if not actually confused. The
first of these is generality. Although someone who says I saw a reptile is not giving as much information as
someone who says I saw a snake, they
are not being any more vague. That is to say, the notion "reptile" is
as clearly delimitable as the notion "snake", it is just that it
denotes a more inclusive class. Another notion which must be
distinguished from vagueness is abstractness. For instance, the notion
of "entailment" is abstract, but is relatively well defined,
and therefore not vague.
e. Basicness
Another
dimension along which descriptive meanings can vary is that of basicness: some meanings are
considered more basic than others. This is a complex topic and cannot be fully
explored here. There are several differentinterpretations of the notion. We
shall look at three broad ways of thinking of a basicness.
In many, extremely
varied, approaches to language and meaning a distinction is made between words
or features which are close to concrete everyday experience, and those which,
though in some way ultimately derived from these, are to various degrees remote
from actual bodily experience. For instance, the meaning of cold can be directly
experienced through the senses, but the meaning of gradable as applied to adjectives (e.g. a little bit/slightly/ quite/rather/very/extremely cold) cannot,
though there is undoubtedly a connection of some sort between bodily
experiences of coldness and the abstract notion of gradability.
f. Viewpoint
A
number of linguistic expressions encode as part of their meaning a particular viewpoint on the events or
states of affairs designated. Perhaps the most obvious example of this is
provided by deictic expressions such as this,
that, here, there, now, then, and so on, which are usually
claimed to encode the viewpoint of the speaker at the moment of utterance. So,
for instance, the book on the table,
if it was valid for one speaker in a particular context, would be
valid for anyone present; however, the validity of this book here, as a description of the same book, would clearly
depend on the position of the speaker relative to the book in question.
2. Relative dimensions
Under
the next three headings, we shall look at parameters which relate not so much
to complete meanings, but to semantic features which form part of a complete
lexical sense.
a. Necessity and expectedness
The first parameter
is necessity. The simple view of this parameter is to make a sharp dichotomy
between necessary and contingent logical relationships, and use entailment to
determine whether or not a feature is necessary. On the basis of the following
we could say that "being an animal" is a necessary feature of dog.
b. Sufficiency
Sufficiency
is a kind of converse of necessity. We normally speak of the joint sufficiency of a set of features
(for instance, the features MALE and HORSE are jointly sufficient to
guarantee that anything possessing them is a stallion). We may interpret
the notion as it applies to a single feature in terms of diagnosticity, an obviously gradable notion. Salience Things
which are salient stand out from their background in some way, and have a
superior power of commanding attention. This property may be shown by one
linguistic element vis-a-vis other elements in a larger expression, or
by one feature of the meaning of a word vis-a-vis other features of the
same word. I would like to distinguish two types of saliency (without, however,
wishing to deny their interrelationships). One way of interpreting the notion
of salience is in terms of the ease of access of information. Obviously,
features which are easy to get at are going to play a larger role in semantic
processing in real time than those which are harder to get at. Certainly, many
of the so-called prototype effects observable between items and categories seem
to depend on ease of access, and it would be reasonable to expect the same to
be true of features.[7]
CHAPTER III
CONSLUSION
According to Oxford
Advanced Learner’s, descriptive is saying what something is like; describing
something: the descriptive passages in the novel. While, Meaning is the thing or idea that sounds, word, sign, etc.
Descriptive
meaning is a dimension of expression meaning or descriptive meaning is contained in
the meaning of each word. Meaning indicated by the symbol itself. Intended
meaning is the meaning that is still happening in the community of languages.Descriptive meaning contributes to a bare
presentation of facts.If someone said, "Take a glass
of water," then surely brought water instead of juice or mercury.
Understand the meaning of the word water, because it brings the water as we
wish.
REFERENCES
Mansoerpateda, Semantic
Leksikal, (Jakarta: RinekaCipta, 2010)
Mark
Schroeder, ‘Semantics, Moral Forthcoming in the International Encyclopedia
of Ethics. (University of Southern California, 2008)
Oxford Advanced Learner’s
Dictionary.
Review of lobner,
Sebastian, understanding semantics, (London: Arnold publisher: 2002)
Cruse Alan D, Meaning in language An introduction to
semantics and pragmatics, (Oxford University Press, New york, 2000).
[1]Review of Löbner, Sebastian, Understanding Semantics.(London:Arnold
Publishers.2002), p 38.
[2]
Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary. P.395.
[4]Ibid.,
P. 920.
[5] Mark Schroeder,‘Semantics, MoralForthcoming in the
International Encyclopedia of Ethics.(University of Southern California,
2008)16: 447-465.
[6]Mansoerpateda,
Semantic Leksikal, (Jakarta: RinekaCipta, 2010), p 99.
[7] Cruse Alan D, Meaning in
language An introduction to semantics and pragmatics, (Oxford University Press,
New york, 2000), p. 46
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar